Attenuation: How well do they work?

bubs_42

Well-known member
Supporter
Well for this guy, just as well as a really good master volume. The Badcat Leash works great for knocking down a few db's without effecting the amp. But if your a NMV lover like myself you know that with no MV everything counts from your fingers to the speaker. When anything gets in the way it will affect the tone. So lowering the leash past half you will loose the speaker break up and feel of the amp. It sounded just like if I turn the amp down like I had it at practice. Goes to show you how important that speaker is in your tone. No matter how hard the amp is still working it is still the sum of all the parts. 

 
I think attenuators work well if you are realistic about them. They will change the tone of  your amp to a greater or lesser degree depending on the unit and the amp.A significant part as bubs mentioned is the interaction of the speakers.  I look at it as a part of the signal chain like a pedal it will affect your sound. The people that are chasing the cranked stack sound at bedroom volumes are always going to be disappointed. 

I've used and owned many and some work better with some amps than others, some amps just don't seem to like any attenuators. Of all the ones I've used I've landed on the Aracom and Alex as my two favorites. The Alex seems to work well with Marshall style amps but less so with Fendery or cleaner amps. The Aracom works very well with pretty much everything. They have gotten much better in the past 10 years from the Marshall Power brake that I started with, then the Dr Z Airbrake,, THD hot plate, Ultimate Attenuator, then the Aracom, Alex, Faustine, Rockcrusher, Leash, etc.. really upped the game. Now you have the Freytette Power Station that Attenuates and re-amps with a bunch of other features as well. Just one more piece of the puzzle. 

All in all an amp with a really good master is more convenient, but it's still fun to wind up a non-master Marshall with a good attenuator. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have the Unleash and previously had the Rockcrusher.

The RC was great, except that I felt like it was either too much attenuation or too little (it's got a rotary switch, not a pot, for its main attenuation).  

The Unleash is great too, but it's a reamping box...  So it completely reduces your signal to line level and then sends it as input to a class D amp to make it louder.  It's a great design, but again, it's different.

Neither was perfect, but I didn't have much of an option when I was using my Fryette Deliverance 60.  It's a dual KT88 amp that's loud AF.  Even at a modest setting on the knobs, it was too loud for most uses with my 212 so my options were: don't use it, play clean, or attenuate. :)

 
Yup...all my amps but one are NMV.....I live with them cranked so attenuators are my friends....Weber Mass is good for knocking a few dubs off at a gig...,my Badcat Unleash is awesome....doesn't seem to affect the amp tone at all, but as has been stated, less juice hitting the speakers has a tremendous effect on tone. If I am gonna record with an attenuator, I reach for a speaker that will still break up at whatever volume.....but that is me. I prefer to crank the amp with no attenuator and record that way, but once in a while that isn't feasible, especially with a blonde Bassman....

 
I love the Weber Mini MASS that I have mounted in the back of my 18 Watter clone.  Since the amp only has 2 knobs, Volume and Tone, I use the MASS as a master volume.  The Volume control changes the over all gain, though a lot of the dirt comes from output stage, unlike true MV amps.

Overall, the MASS sounds good.  When I use it to tweak the volume, I have no complaints with its effect on tone. Down at bedroom levels, it's not totally transparent but it's still pretty good. 

The trick is to get "close" by using an appropriately-sized amp for the gig/application, then fine-tune it with the attenuator.  An 18 Watter doesn't really sound like a wound-up 100-watt Plexi, but if you throttle them both down to the same apartment-friendly volume, the little amp with a little bit of attenuation is going to sound better than the big amp with gobs of attenuation.

It's also going to be a lot cheaper when it's time to retube the output stage. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Are they safe?
Way more reliable than when we use to use, obtain way back when.(Marshall brake, Sholz power soak, etc.)

When Andy made the THD unit, that was a step, leap, in the right direction. But, primarily designed for a Marshall head.

 
I always used Marshall Power Brakes.  I had a white one to match my white JCM800 1/2 stack.  Worked okay, but I hated the clicky settings.  The perfect level was always in between whatever settings I was using.

 
I always used Marshall Power Brakes.  I had a white one to match my white JCM800 1/2 stack.  Worked okay, but I hated the clicky settings.  The perfect level was always in between whatever settings I was using.
Had one for my 100 Watt Laney back in the day. The Badcat Leash is like having a volume pot, just turn til you hear what you want. 

 
Never used one... Don't trust them... Are they safe?  :huh:
Most of the time, the problem is people using one on an amp with really old tubes, that ran fine at low volumes, but baked the moment they were turned up, or when they figured their tubes would last as long as usually, forgetting they're being cranked to the tilt.

 
Using a 50W older version Weber Mass with my JMP 50 watter. The JMP was modded with a bootstrap master back in the 70's. Still to loud for rehersal. With the Weber Mass I can knock it down to a good level. Still loud, still sounds great.

My band mate uses a reissue 100W JMP, non master volume. He has something similiar to the Ultimate Attenuator, but build by someone here in town. That one works very well and takes down those 100 watts of bone crusing power to reasonable levels.

The trick is to set your sound with the attenuator connected. Don't set your sound, then plug it in.  

 
You would also need to use lower wattage speakers, that are yet voiced the same to keep all the variables consistent.  

Today you are better off with an Axe Fx or Kemper unless you're doing stadium gigs.   

 
You would also need to use lower wattage speakers, that are yet voiced the same to keep all the variables consistent.  

Today you are better off with an Axe Fx or Kemper unless you're doing stadium gigs.   
Working on getting a Greenback now for this amp. 

As for the Axe or Kemper, I use one sound, i'd never ever need any of that other stuff. 

 
Limited experience with them but I did have a newer THD Hotplate hooked up to a Soldano style amp, it definitely changed the tone even with slight attenuation. Not that it sounded bad, just different. Not a big fan but realistically, most amps sound pretty different at bedroom volumes versus venue volumes. The good side was I sold it for close to what I bought it for new.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Got a power brake in my Dr. Z Maz Jr.  Does exactly what it's supposed to do, and I don't have to worry about compatibility (presuming that there's anything to worry about).

 
Back
Top