my first response was very positive, and I wouldn't kick it out of my man cave, but the more I look at it, I really like the grain on the top and feel like the stripes detract from the top. But then I look again, and like it. So yea. I dig. It probably wouldn't be as memorable if it was just a great top.
OK, I just saw the original before being painted, and that top was amazing, I now feel like even painting it red was a crime against nature. If I never saw it unpainted I could love it, but having seen the top, it is like a model who was beautiful but messed herself up with too much surgery. (I would use Farah as an example, but will not out of respect) (I guess that is too late now, so anyway, she was beautiful to the end, but stunning pre-surgery)