Does gear REALLY matter??

Toby's post stated that his sound followed him from a pod in Korea to a tube amp in Nashville. Carlos sounds the same on a solid state amp and single coils at Woodstock to humbucker and a Boogie. Everybody thought Zep I was a Les Paul and a Marshall....

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Tube amps (specifically of the 50-watt and higher variety) are similar to muscle cars in that they're impractical in most applications, but god damn if there isn't a visceral reaction when you play/drive one that you don't get from, say, a lunchbox amp, a modeler or a Prius. To me, a great tube amp is a living, breathing thing that doesn't just reproduce sound but actually interacts with you as you play. Of course, I did a lot of acid back in the day, so maybe that's where that comes from.

I will always prefer tube heads until I take the dirt nap. The thing that has gone the way of the dodo for me is lugging huge speaker cabinets around. Nothing sounds like a 4x12, it's true, but you can get close enough for rock and roll with a quality 1x12 and you won't get the stink eye from a sound guy or venue owner simply for showing up with one. 

 
Tone is in the sound guy.  Love it!

@polara - Who bought your Shishkov?  Is that the first one that has a second owner?

 
The fella using the gear is a lot more important than the gear. That said, there's not a thing wrong with collecting nice stuff.



 
Last edited by a moderator:
IMO, as long as you have a guitar that you like and it can adequately convey what your fingers do, anything after that doesn't matter as long as you can get whatever sound is in your head recorded.  It cetainly doesn't matter live because 

99.999 percent of anyone who hears you cannot tell good tone from bad or if you are even really in tune.

it's the player and the song, not the gear.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Tube amps (specifically of the 50-watt and higher variety) are similar to muscle cars in that they're impractical in most applications, but god damn if there isn't a visceral reaction when you play/drive one that you don't get from, say, a lunchbox amp, a modeler or a Prius. To me, a great tube amp is a living, breathing thing that doesn't just reproduce sound but actually interacts with you as you play. ...
^^^ THIS! It's this visceral sensation that trumps blind listening tests and all manner of artificial means to differentiate one from another. Music is meant to communicate emotion between the artist and the listener. The true test isn't higher highs, lower lows, or whatever you can hear and identify that makes the difference, it's which signal chain best conveys the emotion, not just to the audience, but to the guitarist,  too.

I will always prefer tube heads until I take the dirt nap. ... Nothing sounds like a 4x12, but you can get close enough for rock and roll with a quality 1x12 ...
According to a profile I read several years ago, Santana's main tone source even for large concert venue's is a Mesa/Boogie 1x12 that is mic'd up.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
^^^ THIS! It's this visceral sensation that trumps blind listening tests and all manner of artificial means to differentiate one from another. Music is meant to communicate emotion between the artist and the listener. The true test isn't higher highs, lower lows, or whatever you can hear and identify that makes the difference, it's which signal chain best conveys the emotion, not just to the audience, but to the buy playing the guitar too.

According to a profile I read several years ago, Santana's main tone source even for large concert venue's is a Mesa/Boogie 1x12 that is mic'd up.
A more recent article did a pretty detailed outline of what he uses live. Apparently it includes that original Boogie, as well as a PAIR (EACH!) of Dumble ODS amps AND Bludotone ("Dumble-ish) amps. Quite a bit of "cash and carry" in that rig, but if ya got it, why not flaunt it? Arguably there is a pretty direct line from Fender to Boogie to Dumble, so it is not surprising that "his sound" traces back to that. And I am fairly confident he could satisfy the crowd with ONLY the Mesa (thru a great PA system).

BTW, the progression for such as Larry Carlton also follows the Fender to Boogie to Dumble path.

Boogies were the original hotrodded Fenders and Dumble, to no small degree, reworked that formula, for better or worse.

http://www.premierguitar.com/articles/20782-rig-rundown-carlos-santana

 
15 hours ago, JohnnyB said:

Tone is in YOUR BRAIN. Tone is your vision of how you want to sound. Your hands, your gear, all of those contribute to the final audible result. But yes, the hands are the first link in interpreting the mental vision with the audible outcome.

A good example of this was Joe Pass playing a Fender Jazzmaster. When he was in drug rehab, the only guitar in the facility was a Jazzmaster owned by Synanon itself. So Joe played it, and in doing so he managed to adjust the controls and his playing technique to get the sounds he wanted. At the end of his stay he recorded an album, "Sounds of Synanon" with the Jazzmaster. Still, the guitars he played when he got out were often a custom D'Aquisto, Gibson L5, or Gibson Super 400.

I apologize ahead of time for getting off-topic, but, man, I haven't heard about Synanon since I was a kid. Having grown up in SoCal, we had family friends whose son became a high-up member of Synanon, and I remember going and staying with his mom there at the Santa Monica building in the days when everyone (including the women) shaved their heads and lived like a hippy-dippy commune. Frankly, those folks were nuts. I only spent a few days there visiting as a kid, and boy was I happy to go back home. 

 
 In my experience, digital can be fantastic for recording purposes, They can come close with heavy metal, high gain sounds or heavily processed sounds, but in my experience, nowhere near close when it comes to cleaner styles. Haven't tried the Kemper yet, but I'm half willing to bet I'll have the same result. 
You're right on the money with this observation. I play 95% of our set using just two Kemper profiles (both variations of EVH5150/Mesa 4x12" with V30's dual-miked with an SM57 and a Neumann) and they both melt faces. The cleaner profiles I use (Fender Twin etc.) just aren't as good, harmonically rich, or as responsive. We just bought an original old Roland JC120 to see if we can get better clean tone profiles.

 
Does gear matter?  To me it does but to a point.  The fingers matter more.

I have some nice gear and get very good sounds being an Axe FX convert after years with tube amps.

As for guitars I'll always gravitate to what I can afford.  I used to rely on cheaper well set up guitars back in the day but that doesnt mean I dont prefer higher quality (and often more expensive) custom instruments. 

 
As long as I have one of my three Flextone III amps (mono 1x12) with gold leaf Marshall logos and one of my two controller pedal boards, I'll be fine.  I use two amp models, the compressor, delay, chorus/flange and the wah.  I get no deeper.  I just sold my Helix.  It was so good, I hated it.  I don't need that many choices.  Guitars, however, I do. 

I play at a very low volume.  I have really good microphones (Royer).  The JCM Silver Jubilee and 100wt Plexi work well in a live band situation.  If I have to crank up, not so much. So, I have to have a good PA.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Some good points here, and yeah gear matters.

  • Give me a Les Paul and a JCM800 and I'll make one sound
  • A Strat into a Pignose another
  • A Yairi classical another
  • A piano another
  • A trombone another
  • A bag of marbles yet another
There's only so much tone coming from the fingers. But I've come to the conclusion that if I have decent-quality electric guitar essentials - solid body guitar, cable, dirt/delay/modulation, amplification - I'll always end up sounding pretty much he same whether the logos on said gear are Huber and Klon and Dumble, or Cort and Boss and Crate. 

Obviously you should ENJOY the gear. Like I sold my Shishkov because the big pointy shape was weird to hold. But functionally it's not really that vital to be picky about gear, I think.
Yeah, but does the musical phrase you play sound like you in all those cases?  

 
I think, to some extent, the most important role gear plays can be inspiration. It may or may not make you sound a certain way (I'm one of those who tends to sound the same on everything for better or worse), but if hearing a certain sound through a Fender twin, finding a tone on a Kemper, the way the light hits your R9, or the wicked sounds you are getting out of a $200 Yamaha gives you a certain feeling, then it matters. 

 
It really only matters if you want it to matter and to the folks like us who listen to tone.  But if it gets you to play your best, then sure, it matters.  Look at the rig rundown videos and how ridiculous some of those things are.  Billy Gibbons' tech has a digital EQ that he makes every guitar have the same EQ curve so Billy can play all those wacky guitars and the same sound is basically coming out.  However, I'm pretty sure if you gave Billy a tele and an old single knob amp from the 50s, he could still pull his songs and his identity from it. 

 
Gear matters -- absolutely. Gear is usually an evolving process (sometime devolving) in a guitarist's arsenal, and hopefully his skill is evolving too and the two keep pace.  Sure great players can coax great things out of less than stellar gear -- but bad gear -- as in guitars that can't be intoned or tuned, or amps that sound like ass, or stuff that fritz'-out and breaks down.... it's like buying cheap tools. I've got great gear and great tools.... and when I put my wrench on something it doesn't slip and chew the heads off bolts --- I'm a shitty mechanic but my tools wont fuck up your engine - my lack of skill will.  Bad music gear is the same.  Don't believe me? Go to a local blues jam and put an old peavey bandit on the stage and watch shitty players and seasoned pros sound like the same ass.  Gear matters.

 
Back
Top