Does gear REALLY matter??

The question is still this, how come Toby sounded the same in Korea with a pod as he does in Nashville with a boogie? 

 
The question is still this, how come Toby sounded the same in Korea with a pod as he does in Nashville with a boogie? 
The answer is, there is not that much difference. In Korea Toby would dial in a similar profile he would boogie in Nashville just brcause Toby wants to be Toby.

Physically, the Pod is only one piece of gear. Logically, it is a container of any kind of real gear. You could even think of kempering a Pod. Whether it makes sense or not, the Kemper would then become a Pod in profile. 

 
Does gear really matter?

Not in a vacuum

Not in Space

Not underwater

Not as a backline for Justin Beiber.

Not as a backline for Prince (He's DEAD Jim!!)

Not as a backline for St. Vincent.

 
Until 1971 or so, Chinese imports were very restricted here and there weren't any Chinese products of any kind for guitar coming into our country at that time, and if there were anything made by them back then it would have been total crap; they couldn't build a working ball point pen back then (a bit of hyperbole :-)
The crappy electric guitar imports in the 50's, 60's and early 70's were coming from Japan, although, some very good acoustics were coming from Japan in the late 60's.

AFAIK we had no trade with China at all back then.

In 1972 Nixon was the first person to go there and start any kind of relations.

 
Does gear really matter?

Not in a vacuum

Not in Space

Not underwater

Not as a backline for Justin Beiber.

Not as a backline for Prince (He's DEAD Jim!!)

Not as a backline for St. Vincent.
That won't stop someone from hauling it around for forever, or trying to find a buyer in unlikely places:  :rolleyes:   :lol:


Edited to add:  In space, no one can hear your guitar or amp scream.   :lol:   :ph34r:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Gear to a guitarist is like colors to an artist... you start with black a white, move on to all kinds of glorious colors... then after time you can go back to simply black and white and still move people.
Black, white and gray.  Black, white, and Gray.  The Oxford comma the second time for emphasis. 

 
I believe so.... due to my experience of changing to better and better guitars...

1 Chinese Strat copy - sounded terrible

2 American Standard Strat - sounded very nice

3 Hamer Monaco Elite - sounded FANTASTIC.

So there... :-)

(True story, using same home recording technique.)

-

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hendrix-Pedals-True-Bypass.jpg


 
I thought I'd revisit this topic from a different perspective or two:

My wife apparently can hear the difference when I'm using my Mesa, versus any other amp. She prefers the Mesa and when I play through anything else, digital or tube, she calls it "noisy".

My 3 year old son went through my pedalboard and turned all the knobs. The analog pedals I could quickly get back, but even with the analog layout, I'm still trying to figure out why my TC Electronic pedals aren't quite the same as before. I don't know why - probably due to advancing age - but despite being mentally on top of my game in my career, if I don't use a piece of technology daily, I have to go through the entire learning curve from scratch. I'm rereading the manuals for my TC pedals, and I don't think they're that complicated. I shudder to think about having to relearn something like a Kemper. 

Someone PLEASE tell me that technology has gotten way out of hand, and it's not me with a diminishing mental ability to understand this shit.... :P

 
Roger Mayer said he used to travel with the JHE with multiple FuzzFaces. At one show, Jimi's screaming at Roger to swap out his fuzzbox. Roger complies, Jimi screams again to bring out another. Roger again complies. This happens five or six times until Roger finally plugged in the original box (unknown to Hendrix) that Jimi said was "bad." Jimi smiled, "now THAT'S what I'm talking about." Mayer said he shrugged and laughed it off. He quipped, "it's funny, but I think a lot of guitar players are like that."


This Roger Mayer story reminded me of a similar thing I used to do in my studio with people with lead ears. After the first couple of requests to tweak an EQ on a track in a mix, if I had it sounding good, I'd fake the next knob twists to see if I got a, "That's better" without any real EQ change. Usually worked.

I used to produce/engineer and do the voiceovers for a NYC area ad agency. The owner was so paranoid about keeping his one client happy that he would drive me crazy overthinking if the finished spot was perfect. After dealing with him breathing over my shoulder the first few sessions, I started to just do them on my own and have the board set up with the finished mix when he arrived. If he still felt he had to "add more highs on the voice" or whatever, I always faked the EQ or volume changes....and he always would say, "Yeah, that's better."

Personally. I don't think gear matters much. If you have the basics, you can get it done. 99 percent of an audience cannot tell what kind of gear you are using or if you play a few mistakes.

I recently had a guy contact me about rereleasing a song I wrote/recorded decades ago. After raving about it, he asked how many tracks the master was. He got all weird when I said, "Probably 8.....Sgt. Pepper was done on four, so it really doesn't matter. If it makes you feel better, I can bump it over to 16 and lie."

There are famous players who made their own guitars or amps...or whose main axes are glued back together from broken parts. Or even mistakes that become part of the finished work.

It's not the gear that matters all that much, IMO. It's more about capturing a magic moment and documenting it in some form that can later be reproduced/played back.

 
All gear has limitations.

The point of professional-level gear is to either eliminate as many limitations as possible, or to make sure the limitations are (more) restricted to the areas the artist doesn't want to explore.

However, one mandatory aspect of Art is limitations. With no limitations at all, Art is just wankery that only the Artist can appreciate.  The best Art is usually* created by working under restrictions and limitations.

So top Artists are those able to create great Art while working within the limitations of their chosen medium. EVH was a great Artist, so his Art wasn't limited by the limitations of his gear in the way you or I would be trying to study and replicate his Artistry.

So to me, the answer is: yes, gear matters...to an extent, and to a different extent depending on the individual and context.

*there are exceptions to everything. Including that there are exceptions to everything, setting up a logical conundrum that will consume the entire universe if pondered too long.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
"To achieve great things, two things are needed; a plan, and not quite enough time." - Leonard Bernstein

I'd argue there's one more - enough money that you're not scrambling to figure out how you're gonna eat and where you're gonna sleep in the process. ;)  

 
However, one mandatory aspect of Art is limitations. With no limitations at all, Art is just wankery that only the Artist can appreciate.  The best Art is usually* created by working under restrictions and limitations.
"To achieve great things, two things are needed; a plan, and not quite enough time." - Leonard Bernstein

I'd argue there's one more - enough money that you're not scrambling to figure out how you're gonna eat and where you're gonna sleep in the process. ;)  

 
My wife apparently can hear the difference when I'm using my Mesa, versus any other amp. She prefers the Mesa and when I play through anything else, digital or tube, she calls it "noisy".
Our wives should talk. Mine has told me the Mesa is the keeper, so the Marshall is history. She also STRONGLY prefers the Gretsch over the Guild or the Hamer.

I bring this up because she doesn't give a rat's ass about what I paid, or if Jimmy Page used one, or NOS tubes, or tonewoods, or Premier Guitar reviews, or what they say over at TGP. Despite my knob twiddling and such, the songs I write sound different on different instruments. Whether that MATTERS is debatable, but there is a clear effect beyond the player's own ego, lust for shiny toys, and self-delusion.

 
My 3 year old son went through my pedalboard and turned all the knobs. The analog pedals I could quickly get back, but even with the analog layout, I'm still trying to figure out why my TC Electronic pedals aren't quite the same as before. I don't know why - probably due to advancing age - but despite being mentally on top of my game in my career, if I don't use a piece of technology daily, I have to go through the entire learning curve from scratch. I'm rereading the manuals for my TC pedals, and I don't think they're that complicated. I shudder to think about having to relearn something like a Kemper. 

Someone PLEASE tell me that technology has gotten way out of hand, and it's not me with a diminishing mental ability to understand this shit.... :P
There are some of my pedals that have been passed along because they have too much going on.  The people designing pedals are well intentioned if they are providing a pedal that will be used by itself rather than on a pedal board with six other equally capable pedals.  Some of those complicated analog pedals have so many settings that you have more than one range of possibilities.  They are fun, but time consuming when you explore them. 

Guys around here who have been running live sound for years have been caught in a trap of not keeping up with digital mixing consoles.  The sound man for one local venue went to classes on digital boards and now he gets called in for gigs at other venues more than two hours away when some big name acts come through.  The other guys are lost on some gigs.  My old mixing console is absolutely analog, but the manual is almost cryptic in the way it explains the many ways it can be used. 

Change has come for anyone that now works on digital equipment.  Graphic artists have to learn the ins and outs of software and equipment that have replaced ink, paint, and photographic techniques.  Doctors look at digital x-rays, not film, and make their assessments using voice recognition software.  Trains are operated with the aid of computers.  Household paint stores use computers to analyze and mix paint.  Fishing is now assisted with electronic equipment.  The whole world is now having to relearn how to do everything. 

Whether your pedals are analog or digital, technology has gotten to a point that learning the gear takes as long as learning to play the instruments the gear is supposed to enhance. 

 
"All gear has limitations."   I strongly disagree! I can make anything sound crappy! 

HamStd was contacted by Rick Nielsen for me to "Surrender" my Cheap Trick Fan Club Membership on a said performance. 



 
Last edited by a moderator:
While no matter what I use it sounds like me, it is the notes and chords, bending and the vibrato stuff that sounds like me. The sound might not be the same, maybe it does not matter when playing in a band anyway. it is always a mood thing with me. I had times when my Steve Stevens was my #1 guitar. Then I got other guitars and at some time I had a hard time to "connect" with the Steve Stevens. I once thought my RD Artist is a piece of junk, and when I play it through my Marshall it really doesn't sound good but when I use it on the clean channel of the Fender Prosonic it sounds quite well. Right now I am in my "Strat" phase, and while I like the Fenders I have, my Chap Deluxe also gives me a nice funky tone, even with the EMG's. Also with the amps, I am in the mood to use the Prosonic recently, yet I helped out at a gig using my Marshall and I thought "wow, it sounds fantastic tonight!" And  I think, I might have a different approach to my equipment right now and value a bit more what I have instead of letting GAS decide what to use. Cheap gear doesn't mean it is crap. Especially when buying used. Several of my Hamer guitars didn't cost me more than $500. I once got a Kramer Focus 3000 very cheap (about $200). Sometimes a sunburst Strat inspires me more than a violet one, and sometimes I just love the neck profile of my Cali. But what I play I can play on any of my guitars, and that is what makes me sound like me.

 
I once had a Kendrick Tweed Deluxe clone, great amp, loved playing it, but more often than not I found myself turning both volume knobs up (they're interactive) and doing the Neil Young/Crazy Horse thing and nothing else, so I got rid of it.  Once had a Hiroshi Kid-made Gibson '58 Flying V copy/clone in Korina, it played and sounded great, but again I found myself channeling (or trying to channel) Albert King WAY too often, so away it went.  Moral:  Sometimes you can get a little TOO successful at copping someone's tone, it doesn't have to be exact (especially with my playing skills ;) :lol: ), but getting a little TOO close for one's taste can turn a creative playing rut into a big 'ol repetitive ditch.  YMMV.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top