Ahhh Ebay. I have had mostly good experiences but there have been a few humdingers.... I sold an 1983 Ibanez Roadstar for what I thought was a good average price, about $275. I described it as a 6 out of 10, with normal wear for its age, commented on the scratches and dings etc... The buyer demanded a partial refund becuase he said he was not pleased with the condition. The thing is, I was conservative with my ratings, the guitar had little fretwear, minor surface scratches and one ding on the horn. I didn't want to deal with the Paypal/Ebay buyer remorse BS so I refunded him 25%. Total crap and it has kept me off Ebay ever since.
/emoticons/default_cool.png
I had pretty much an identical problem.
I described normal wear for a 20-year-old guitar, he didn't like the grooves in the frets that didn't affect playability (no buzzes or fretouts), wanted me to pay for a recrown.
I told him if he expected a mint frets, he should pay mint prices, everything was as described.
He disputed it and won. I gave him a refund without rancor as soon as the decision was announced, he sent the guitar back immediately, and neither of us left *any* feedback.
So even though neither of us was happy with the other, he didn't get vindictive on me.
Even though it wasn't the result I wanted, I can't consider it a failed experience.
In another anecdote, I just had another buyer flake out on me. I thought I had my settings to refuse anyone with zero feedback, but eBay let him bid.
I've sent out a 2nd chance offer, the 2nd highest bidder didn't take it. I would think that the winning bidder may have been the 2nd highest bidder outbidding himself to get out of a purchase w/o getting negative feedback, but that seems way too complicated for reality. Plus, I have never yet taken a 2nd-chance offer myself...by the time I know I'm not going to win a bid, I have already put in a bid on another guitar/item, or I changed my mind about wanting it.
Luckily, it was a project guitar not worth much, so I didn't lose much by not selling it.