Gibson QC.

LarryUK

New member
I’m a member on quite a few guitar pages on Facebook and there have been some shocking posts of terrible QC coming from the USA factory. Someone has just received his 3rd classic now. The quality is abysmal. The photo of the frets is the third one. The case and nut is the second one. No wonder there’s talk of them going bust. 

3D68F4ED-1486-4BA5-B2A9-3BF8A9D9541E.jpeg

C9A8BBD2-74A6-424A-915F-E69F8BD50CB1.jpeg

A4E7517F-B7A9-48C2-A4D6-81CD1801BDF9.jpeg

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Appalling.  There really isn’t any justification for that sort of sloppy QC on a higher end instrument.  

 
The seeming endless cases of shitty QC at Gibson are both well documented and old news, unfortunately. That particular horse has been beaten to a smear online. It's both appalling as DBraz states and a possible death knell for a company that struggles with leadership and how to remain relevant in an age where guitar no longer is.

 
The need to meet a production quota can be a contributing factor.  We got spoiled by Hamer taking the time to do the job right.  As long as Sterling Ball is in charge at Music Man he is going to make sure the company never grows beyond a point where the quality suffers.

 
This is one of the reasons I only buy used guitars anymore.  I think the last guitar I purchased new was a USA-made Hamer, back when they were still in business.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hmm, Gibson doesn't make the cases though. They are all made by TKL. I have noticed that TKL cases don't seem to be as well made as they used to be, in terms of fit and finish. Sure it's easy to repair that kind of issue with a case, but you shouldn't have to on a new case.

 
I bought 3 new Gibsons last year.  All of them had glaring finishing flaws. If I wouldn't have got them for "below used" prices, i would have sent them back immediately. 

 
Sadly, they seem to sink money into endorsements etc. rather than QC.   I get you have to do some promotion, but not at the expense of quality. 

 
This is nothing new. I was told years ago if I ever found a Gibson without finish flaws it was most likely a fake.

 
I bought 3 new Gibsons last year.  All of them had glaring finishing flaws. If I wouldn't have got them for "below used" prices, i would have sent them back immediately. 
Funny enough, the black SG that I had gotten "Scratch n' dent" from AMS was pretty much perfect. The only thing I found was a little binding error, like the one up at top, from overzealous scraping the finish off the binding.

Buying a new SG this year will be... an adventure. Hopefully sweetwaters 52 point inspection will pick up horrible finish and setup issues.

 
I’m a member on quite a few guitar pages on Facebook and there have been some shocking posts of terrible QC coming from the USA factory. Someone has just received his 3rd classic now. The quality is abysmal. The photo of the frets is the third one. The case and nut is the second one. No wonder there’s talk of them going bust. 

View attachment 19775

View attachment 19776

View attachment 19777
I just looked again at these, the guitar looks like it's years old.  

 
"Only a Gibson is good enough"...I get it now!  Just "good enough", as opposed to "EXCELLENT"?

 
Hmm, Gibson doesn't make the cases though. They are all made by TKL. I have noticed that TKL cases don't seem to be as well made as they used to be, in terms of fit and finish. Sure it's easy to repair that kind of issue with a case, but you shouldn't have to on a new case.
I think TKL may have shifted some of their case production (hopefully not all of it) from Canada to China, within the last few years.  Back when I was shopping for used cases for guitars, I always asked to confirm that they were Canadian made, and not somewhere else.  If it was made elsewhere, or the seller didn't know, or it looked suspicious (Chinese cases seem to use chromed parts that look TOO chromed/shiny to me, almost like they glow in the dark) then hard pass.

"Only a Gibson is good enough"...I get it now!  Just "good enough", as opposed to "EXCELLENT"?
IIRC, seems like I remember reading about a guitar manufacturer, back in the '40's or '50's (I think it was Epiphone before they were bought by Gibson back in the late '50's, or perhaps Gretsch), used the slogan: 'When "good enough" isn't good enough'; back in the day when Gibson was actively using their slogan like on their 'Banner'-logo'd acoustic headstocks.  Or it coulda been later, but I don't think it was ever used by Fender...I think that competitor's slogan was mentioned somewhere in the Gibson 'Fabulous Flat-top Guitars' book, anybody have that book handy?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Buying a new SG this year will be... an adventure. Hopefully sweetwaters 52 point inspection will pick up horrible finish and setup issues.
Don't count on it, and that's a smack at Sweetwater, not Gibson. I had a D-18 come through two weeks ago that its owner told me he paid extra to have SW's in-house pro setup done before it left them. They didn't touch anything ... or if they did, the pro was so WTF they somehow managed to mess up even Nazareth's factory high-side set-up  - because I could have shot arrows off that guitar the way it arrived. I thought it was a fluke, but a repair peer in my market told me he also recently received four Sweetwater guitars that were brought to him after the in-house thing didn't pass the owners' approvals. That 55-point SW inspection apparently doesn't include examining anything pertaining to action or playability.

 
Back
Top