Mesa amps

bassbora

Member
I have an amp question for the wise people of the Hamer realm.  I have been thinking of getting of getting a guitar amp (I have been using an old bass combo) for home use and who knows if I might gig one day.  I am a gigging bass player and I use Mesa so my first thoughts were Mesa combo.  

I play guitar quite a bit at home and I mostly play hard rock and metal.  The criteria for me is a rich, warm clean tone not glassy fender cleans and I like to use pedals to get different drive/distortion so there is a variety to the tone.  I currently have on my pedal board Wampler Triple Wreck and Pinnacle Deluxe V2 and OCD.  They all sound different and give me what I need.

I am a sucker for old gear so I was looking for old Mesa amps.  So I have come across two old mesa amps quite different and I was going to see what people here thought about pros and cons of each.

Studio 22+ and '89 model in ok condition and the other is Mark III (blue stripe) but I dont know the age but its around 25 years old.  Price is not that different but I dont think I need the volume from the Mark and the weight sounds like it is a killer.  Then again if it will just stay at home in one place the weight is not going to be an issue.

I have also spotted three others but they are quite far away and shipping is not an option so it would require some effort in getting them but they are '86 Mark III black stripe, Stiletto Ace and Rectoverb 50.

I dont think reverb is going to be any issue since I am thinking about getting Wampler Ethereal which would cover anything I would like in that department.

So what do you guys think?

 
Get the 22+, it is lighter, and takes pedals well. You won't be disappointed in the 22+ at all. I personally liked the Ace but a few others here did not like it, and you definitely are NOT going to get a glassy clean tones out if it or a Recto 50.

 
I don't think you can go wrong with either. If they don't both have the onboard five-band slider EQ (I consider that a necessity for any older Boogie), I'd get the one that has it. If they both have EQ, I'd get the Mark III personally for the "deep" push-pull (I don't think the .22 has that) and the sweet layer of phat and boom the "deep" control adds to all sounds, which is particularly nice if we're talking combos and even nicer if you want to thicken up strat and tele tones on the fly. Plus big wattage equates to big clean headroom, which is always nice for pedals.

Sounds like both amps are older, you may want to be thinking now about a TLC/checkup for whichever you get and if so, sending it back to Boogie for them to do the work. I've sent two or three amps to Petaluma over the years and they have been great to work with, their prices were in line with what I'd pay a typical reputable amp repair guy and it's only fair to assume that since they designed and built the amps, they know their circuits, have OEM components or suitable value/quality replacements, etc. Plus they can mod their circuits a little to better hit your expectations and wish list (keep reading)

For what it's worth, I've owned a Mark II, I think five or six Mark IIIs, three Mark IVs, one Mark V and an assortment of Dual Recs, Rectoverbs and Tremoverbs. I deduced over many years of ins-and-outs that the Mark IIIs are my favorite for my ears, hands and tastes. My current and last Mark III (Jan. 1990 green stripe) was sent back to the factory and they re-capped it, they replaced whatever had dried out or drifted over time, added a dedicated R2 volume on the back panel (STELLAR mod) and completely overhauled the reverb circuit (down to a new tank) to make it more akin to what's in the Lone Star circuit. Turn time from factory arrival to factory expedite was about a week or so.

 
The 22+ will be good for playing around the house.  If you like the flexibility of the Mark III, go with that one. 

How far apart are the amps in price? 

 
So long as weight is only an issue moving it IN, I'd go with the Mk. Long ago, I bought a 22+ (it was $300 then) as a "lower weight" substitute for moving around. I did not like it nearly as much as the Mk series. Never quite bonded with the 22+, but then a lot of people love it.

 
If the blue stripe Mk III has the GEQ, then it's going to be the best 'metal' amp IMO, as the blue stripe is the most aggressive sounding of the Mk IIIs. As Jeffro mention above, the R2 mod is highly recommended if it doesn't have it already.

For the others you mentioned (all IMO, of course):

Studio 22+ - Good for clean to classic rock but would fall apart for metal. Great for around the house or hanging with a drummer who's not a pounder.

Is that a black dot Mk III? If so, it may have the 105 transformer, which is the same one a as the Mk IIC+ and would be closer in tone and feel to the IIC+ if you did a Mk IIIC+ mod.

Stiletto Ace - There are mods to address it, but man are those some seriously bright amps. I had the Deuce II for a while and just couldn't get used to lack of low-end compared to my Mk IV.

Recto tone? Not for me.

 
Thanks guys for great replies and so much info. Both amps have the GEQ and the price difference is around $165. This is in the UK 

 
I would definitely go for the Mark III but I understand the combo is very, very heavy.  Mine was converted to a head a few years ago.  I used mine with pedals for home practice for years. At home, you aren't going to be loud enough to reveal the true aggressive nature of the MKIII. IMO some of these claims about the differences in stripe color are overstated - your settings, the rig, guitars, pickups and loudness are going to make the most difference in how the amp sounds. It is amazingly flexible once you understand the controls. In either case, the amp is due for a cap job.

 
Ahh crap. Just when I was going to send the guy a message about the Mark III he posts he he has sold it. Just my luck.

thanks all for your replies I know now what to look out for 

 
IMO some of these claims about the differences in stripe color are overstated - your settings, the rig, guitars, pickups and loudness are going to make the most difference in how the amp sounds.
I don't know about that. Sure, everything you listed is important to the overall tone and feel, but a blue stripe is a very much different sounding amp than, say, a purple stripe. And a green stripe running it's power amp in pentode, instead of triode has a different feel than any of the others. I had a blue stripe Mk III and wish I had owned a green stripe like Jeff's, as it's basically a blue stripe running in pentode. Of course, I go in between the two settings on my Mk IVa, so it might not of mattered.

The Mesa Boogie Mark wiki has a description of the difference in the stripes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mesa_Boogie_Mark_Series

Another thing to remember is you'll also find 60w, and 100w non-simulclass Mk III which sound different, too.

 
I love the idea of the Stiletto series.  So much so that I've bought a Deuce and an Ace (twice).

Each time the inability to get a tone that wasn't totally dominated by harsh high-mids led to a quick sale.  With the second Ace I tried swapping speakers, tubes and some crazy control settings recommended by online gurus.  Nothing worked and I'm convinced that there is a serious flaw in the design of these amps.

I tried a Studio 22 in a shop once that sounded OK, but it had some of the harsh high end that I disliked in the Stiletto.  

Rich, warm clean (or distorted) sounds are not what I would expect from Mesa amps in general, though my experience is limited.

 
The best "Marshall" I ever had was a Mark III blue stripe.   It didn't do clean very well but the crunch was out of the world.

 
I love the idea of the Stiletto series.  So much so that I've bought a Deuce and an Ace (twice).

Each time the inability to get a tone that wasn't totally dominated by harsh high-mids led to a quick sale.  With the second Ace I tried swapping speakers, tubes and some crazy control settings recommended by online gurus.  Nothing worked and I'm convinced that there is a serious flaw in the design of these amps.

I tried a Studio 22 in a shop once that sounded OK, but it had some of the harsh high end that I disliked in the Stiletto.  

Rich, warm clean (or distorted) sounds are not what I would expect from Mesa amps in general, though my experience is limited.


The Stiletto is inherently bright, because that's how some of the Marshalls sound like that. The trick is to lower down the master volume ever so slightly, then increase the output to compensate. Also, you CAN dial it in a lot less bright, but it sounds less Marshall like doing so IMO. Anyway, I like the brightness. Makes for a good contrast to the other Mesa amps

 
There are a lot of good Mesa Amps out there that are no longer in production. The Studio Caliber series, the Dual Caliber series (DC-2, DC-3, DC-5, DC-10, etc), Nomad Series, Stilletto, etc. There are also the more specialized ones like the Mark Series, Maverick, Blue Angel, etc.

I have a DC-5, and a Maverick, and love them both. Currently looking at picking up a used Nomad, though only the 100 watt beastly version has the graphic EQ.

 
Back
Top