Newport vs 335

Dasein

Well-known member
Supporter
Been allowing myself to think about picking up a new guitar and have the Idea of a Gibson Memphis 335 in my head - but of course there's also the Hamer Newport to consider. Played a couple 335's the other day at our local GC type shop and wasn't particularly impressed (more like slightly underwhelmed) and I spent a lot of time sort of trying to understand what or where the value was in the guitar, and trying to understand quality and the critical elements that make the model what it is - I'm probably 3 to 6 months away from any kind of purchase (gonna sell some firearms probably to finance).

Anyone have experience with and between the two and can you give me some direction to help me even understand what they are in terms of build and playability etc. Just some context to help me as I go through these initial months

 
I know Heritage gets a lot of flack around here, but have you tried a Heritage 535? I used to own the fancier version (555) and thought it was better built and better sounding than its Gibson counterpart.

I currently own a Newport, and though it doesn't sound exactly like a 335, it gets close enough for me. The larger cutaways make it easier for me to reach the upper frets as well. Being a Hamer, the build quality is much high than the Gibson.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
As you've already discovered, it takes some hunting to find a Gibson that can equal Hamer quality. That said, there's nothing that sounds like a 335. A Newport, even the Pro version, is twangier and doesn't get quite the same warm bark that a 335 does. But it has an awesome tone in its own right. I find the Newport shape much more comfortable and suited to my body. The distance between the TOM and stoptail or Bigsby on a Newport makes bends a little loosey goosey and less effective for my playing. But you get used to it with some practice. The Newport is also more prone to feedback if you play loud with significant gain.

I often wish I had the Newport 90 back now that I'm no longer doing the Floyd tribute thing.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I love my Newport Pro Custom. I prefer the sound and playability to the 335's I have tried (but not owned). The Newport felt a lot more solid to me but I guess that's the construction.

If I am honest my Newport is the first guitar I plumb for for that 7/10 rolled off volume/ medium gain thing. Really warm and complex and quite lovely. Having said that mine is strung with 11's which has a big effect.

 
Can anyone talk about setup and intonation - Are there specifics to the different bridges or compromises with intonation that you struggle with - particularly with the 335 -- can they be made to be near perfect? What about the various tops? Is there some obvious ones that are good or bad as far as sound goes?

 
I've played a few 335s at GC and also wasn't impressed. I have a Heritage 535 and love it. I have not played a Newport but just echoing Steel's sentiment about the 535.

 
I love semi-hollows. Went through a LOT of 335s (and close relative Gibsons as well as some by Heritage and two other makers) before deciding on "the one to keep". I was so impressed when I got my first Newport that I planned to sell the 335. Fortunately, I came to my senses in time. I did later pick up a Newport that was custom ordered to more of a 335 feel (center wood block) and it is really nice. But I am still hanging on to the blonde 335......In no small part due to the time it took to find one I considered great.

As per the above, try to actually play as many as possible....The odds of getting a "good one" right off the rack at Guitar Center are not great.

Keep in mind too that it is a bigger guitar----May take some getting used to.

 
The Newport is really its own animal. It is lighter than a 335 will be, and will probably have a bit warmer sound. It's also a bunch smaller, and easier to manage IMHO.

 
In general, 335 types tend to give a darker tonality with a more compressed feel and sound. The Newport Pros equipped with Seth Lovers, in my experience are more lively and open sounding, particularly the spruce top versions, the maple tops are more lively and open sounding too, but with a slightly different personality, more like a Collings. The 335 has its own killer sound, but the differences stem from the wood choices; the laminate top and maple back and sides on the 335 just produce a darker and more compressed sound than the mahogany body, and maple or spruce top of the Newports; with the right 335, it can be quite juicy sounding and lush. The Newport with the Phat Cats are definitely more articulate and 'Twangy' as Yen had mentioned.

They are both great instruments with each their own personality. They are more apples vs oranges than a same kind of product comparison.

Thundersteal mentions Heritage. They make some fine guitars and are worth checking out. /emoticons/default_ph34r.png

- They make some turds too, so I would suggest playing one before you lay out the cash.
I own a 335 gibby, Newport Pro, even an Ibanez AS 103, and I agree 100% with gtrdaddy. The 335 was my last purchase of the 3 as there was no substitute, but they are all fine guitars. I also agree with his Heritage comments as well. YMMV

 
So I'm not crazy for wanting a real 335 -- that's great to hear -- I guess it's just gonna be finding the right one. Should I be scared of Gibson QC issues? Are there years of Gibson products to avoid?

 
As you've already discovered, it takes some hunting to find a Gibson that can equal Hamer quality. That said, there's nothing that sounds like a 335. A Newport, even the Pro version, is twangier and doesn't get quite the same warm bark that a 335 does. But it has an awesome tone in its own right. I find the Newport shape much more comfortable and suited to my body. The distance between the TOM and stoptail or Bigsby on a Newport makes bends a little loosey goosey and less effective for my playing. But you get used to it with some practice. The Newport is also more prone to feedback if you play loud with significant gain.
Agreed on all points - although i could easily coax the 335 i had to ted-style howls.

I had to play a lot of 335s until i gave up the search. Then i bought one from a friend that had "a good one". It was a *very* good one, but the neck had way too much shoulder, and i just didn't get along with it. So, it went back to him.

I suck at describing tones with words, but i think the 335 was more "woody" sounding than the NP P90 that is here. The 335 seemed to break up into a growl when digging in more easily as well. Both are phenomenal guitars - i wouldn't have minded terribly keeping both. They cover a different space.

I think it was harder to find a good 335 than it was to find a good LP.

Maybe that should be Gibson's motto: Only a Gibson is good enough, but you gotta work to find it, b*tch!

 
Man, you guys make me glad I'm pretty ignorant of how each of these sounds. I've been lucky enough to never chase a particular tone or guitar sound, so I can be blissfully ignorant with what I have! /emoticons/default_biggrin.png

 
I ended up with a Yamaha SA2200 - very nice guitar.
I have also heard very good things about the SA2200. VERY consistent. Yamaha makes great stuff.

And of course, I must make the obligatory plug for a Heritage 535. Pretty much made the same way, but with more color options.

Like Gibson, Heritage also has a bunch of smaller semi hollow guitars that might be more suitable.

 
I have a Heritage 535 I love and I have a Gibson 335 I love and I have a Newport I love..sorry not too helpful so far.

The 335s can be confusing to shop for. There were Nashville CS models and those made in Memphis ie the Dots for one.. Then they moved a lot of the CS 335 production (or just labeled them that way not sure) construction to Memphis around 2013 or so. Good reviews on those. The Nashvilles seem to be more money. I found an Ebony 59 Nashville on CL.

Amazon had a sale on Dots a year ago for $2k..and I just got a ridiculous deal on a 2013 CS ES 330 from Amazon warehouse..listed as used acceptable which is their worst rating..and if you call them with any little issue they give a 20% refund right off the bat..listed as used but it was a return I'm sure. Needed a good (or at least my amateur attempt) setup is all. Watch for used deals on Amazon..they pop up once in a while. No risk with their return policy.

There was a thread a long time ago with a comment that stuck with me. Something like "335s are hammers and Newports are scalpels".

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Man, you guys make me glad I'm pretty ignorant of how each of these sounds. I've been lucky enough to never chase a particular tone or guitar sound, so I can be blissfully ignorant with what I have! /emoticons/default_biggrin.png
I thought the same thing until I sat down with a good hollow/semi-hollow-body, at which point I hunted down a Newport and never looked back. They're awesome guitars, though obviously used for different things than, say, my Cali.

 
Back
Top