SD vs. Dimarzio

captjc

New member
Supporter
I've been playing with a lot of pickups as of late. I'm still early in my experiment. One premature conclusion I've developed is that SD makes some of the better true humbuckers, while Dimarzio makes some of the best hum-cancelling "single coil"-ish pickups.

I would enjoy your thoughts. I have both Hamer Daytonas and G&L Legacy "strats" I'm playing with.

 
I agree with your impressions. If you want noiseless in single-coil format, DiMarzio is indeed the way to go. But their humbuckers (like the heralded 36th anniversary PAF model) are good too.

 
I agree with your impressions. If you want noiseless in single-coil format, DiMarzio is indeed the way to go. But their humbuckers (like the heralded 36th anniversary PAF model) are good too.
I will admit that I didn't really try much of the true humbuckers that Dimarzio offers. What I really noticed is that Dimarzio really delved into the noiseless single coil technology.

I have a Paul Gilbert single coil set on the way for my Legacy. Musicians Friend had a $30 off coupon for the weekend. This is the most highly designed set I've tried (Injector bridge and neck with an Area 67 middle). I can't wait.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The DiMarzio PAF is the best neck pickup around IMO, I would have one in all my 22 fret guitars if I'd known that when I started trying new pickups out.

 
The DiMarzio PAF is the best neck pickup around IMO, I would have one in all my 22 fret guitars if I'd known that when I started trying new pickups out.
Thanks for the response. Anything from you single coil guys?
The Hamer Slammer Dimarzio in my SSII sounded great. I have not tried any other Dimarzio singlecoils. Many players really seem to like the Dimarzio Area pickups though, both for tele and strat.I might be in minority, but I personally have found that I really like Dimarzio's humbuckers much better than Seymour Duncans. But I really like Duncans singlecoils. The SSL-1 strat set is awesome, and I now have Antiquities in my T62, and they are really great strat pickups for vintage tone. The Broadcaster and Antiquity neck in my T51 are also stellar sounding. And I absolutely love the Phat Cats.

Seymour is a tele player, so It would make sense that his singlecoils are developed with special detail to tone. I find the Duncan humbuckers to sound best under heavy gain, which I use less and less these days.

 
I think it's very difficult -and inaccurate - to say Brand S is one thing and brand D is another when both have so many products. I'll say though that the DiMarzio 36th PAFs I put in my '81 Special sound great as do the Slammers in my two Phantoms. Oh, and the PAF and Super Distortion in my '79 Japanese Les Paul copy.

Okay, I just realized all my electric guitars have DiMarzios. Weird.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would like to try the 36ths from Dimarzio. I too like the SD Humbuckers and the Dimarzio Single Coils.

 
Another fan of DiMarzio HB's here also. I like lower output PAF'ish style PU's and the old DM PAF's, the Virtual PAF's and 36th Anniversary PAF's rub me the right way over Duncans (though I do like SD's Pearly Gates and Alnico II's for certain applications). Thing I dig about these DiMarzio 'buckers is the wide, useful range of tones you can conjur up with a Hamer's tone circuit and volume controls - seems like every classic HB tone is there for the taking (modern tones, not so much with these pu's, of course - better choices for that available).

Don't know if they're still available, but the Lace Sensor "Blue" was my fave single coil when I used to play those many moons ago...

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The DiMarzio PAF and Super D are both some of my favourite pups, but the Duncan JB, Custom and 59 are just as good.

 
I don't have much experience with DiMarzio's HBs, but I dig their Area pickups. With SD, I've liked everything of theirs I've tried: Seth Lovers, JBs, 59s, P-90s, PhatCats, and Strat Alnico IIs. It's absurd how many choices guitarists have these days.

 
Overall I think I like Dimarzio humbuckers a little better. I've removed SD pickups quite often and replaced with others. The only Dimarzio that I have removed is a Super Distortion. It just didn't have enough warmth. Not a huge JB fan (too compressed) I prefer Nortons or even Carvin M22Ts.

 
I do have SD's a custom, and a custom custom in my newport, but EVERYTHING else has dimarzios. I LOVE the area pickups for singles, and I am a huge fan of the PAF's. What I think Dimarzio does best are the "air" pickups with the mismatched coils, that's brilliant and fantastic sounding.

 
In the end, there are probably comparable pups in either camp. My experiences lean me toward Duncans.

I had some DiMarzio HS2s and HS3s that did not inspire me at all. The wire gauge was so thin that I had a hard time stripping them without them breaking. Still the thinnest, cheapest wires I have ever dealt with in a pickup. I also received a dead PAF Pro that I purchased brand new from Guitar Center. I didn't use it right away and when I finally got around to installing it, one coil was dead. DiMarzio wouldn't repair or accept a return stating that too much time had passed - admittedly my own fault, but had they taken it apart, they would have found it was internally defective and not anything I did. Then, there was the time I bought a 'cream' set for my old Destroyer - a Humbucker from Hell and another PAF Pro. They were completely different shades of cream - so much so that it was noticeable from ten feet away. This was especially troubling for me since DiMarzio went to the trouble of trademarking cream and then couldn't produce consistent shades. That trademark thing still burns me and with so many choices available I have the luxury of avoiding DiMarzio based solely on the fact that I can't get the cream pups I want from anywhere but Larry, and yet he couldn't even send me two cream pups that were the same color.

Just MY experiences, mind you - so my opening line is (now double) probably true.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would like to try the 36ths from Dimarzio. I too like the SD Humbuckers and the Dimarzio Single Coils.
I have the Dimarzio 36ths in a Studio. They actually sound pretty good and I like the bridge better than the neck. I've only owned the guitar for a few weeks and that's what came in it. I'm not much of a humbucker guy and I have a feeling I'm going to end up trying a lot of pickup's in this Studio before I make a final decision. I'll probably try Alnico II's and I also have a brand new pair of 59's that may end up in the Studio. I have two Hamer Artist's with the Stock Seth Lover which sound fantastic. It's all up to the player and the wood of the guitar.

I custom built a Strat a few years ago and I tried about every pickup (Ceramic, Alnico 5) in the guitar. I used Duncan Alnico II's for quite a while and now I have Texas Specials with the Pearly Gates Bridge. On that guitar I think it's just the body that makes it sound like crap compared to my other two Strat's.

Overall I like Single-Coil's in a Strat or Tele. I think that's why I like the Seth Lover's because they are not real fat and pretty close to a single coil in sound.

This probably did not help you.

 
Virtual PAFs were/are the rage in Nashville, at least I was told.

They took the PAF and tried to perfect perfection.

 
Only Seymour Duncans I like are the alnico II pickups. However, the Full Shred sounds pretty good too. That being said, I'm a big fan of Dimarzios, and I have yet to find a pickup that Dimarzio makes that I don't like... /emoticons/default_biggrin.png

 
my fave neck pup is a phatcat! not a fan of neck humbuckers.

i have 2 shredders w/ singlecoil neck pups (jackson PC1 w/ duncan sustainer, hamer mutt w/ emg), not crazy about either's neck pup tone (*love* the sustainer function, tho).

HHB is the pickiest tone guy i'm pals w/, he loves the GFS alnico strat pups, and he typically eschews cheap stuff, so that speaks volumes. but this thread is duncan vs dimarzio...

hard for me to pin a bridge pup down, it depends on the guitar (rio bbq is quite good in my duotone, but that guitar sounded good w/ phatcat or JB in the bridge, too). i'm not crazy about the dimarzio super II in my jackson,

yet i'm kinda over the gear chase and too busy/lazy to fool w/ swapping it out.

i actually like emg bridge buckers in floyded guitars (*gasp*).

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top