Working vs. Collecting

Is it wonky hearing your guitar in standard but then having an amp a half step down?  
If your amp is loud, like a gig playing a VH song, you won't hear what's going on with your guitar acoustically at all, amp overpowers it. Around the house at house volumes, it's kind of wonky. Ask The Muse about that - he thought his Morpheus was broken because it was bleeding the true tuning into the digital detune. Turns out the pedal was fine, he was just hearing the acoustic qualities of the electric along with the amp at bedroom volume.

The moral, as usual, is to simply turn the shit up.

 
Plus, this band plays a half step down.  If I want to play the Cali at home, I have to set it up for standard.  Then I have to set it up again for the band.  And on and on. 
Why you have to tune back to standard if you want to play it at home?

 
I just gotta say,

10_zps2ee9b6c8.png


THAT IS BEAUTUFUL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 
Our list has "evolved" because, in standard tuning, we can no longer hit the notes.  I think people perceive that a tune is played in a lower tuning.  We used to play "Jane" by Starship.  We dropped it a full step.  It just didn't sound right to me.  I remember seeing Foreigner playing Rev on the Red Line in Am instead of Bm.  It sounded hideous.  Just my ear, I guess.

 
Yeah... Call me a snob, but different keys have a different color or feel. Dropping something from the record (or in the case of VH, *raising* it if you do not drop tune) really changed the feel of the song. One that is really odd is Still Loving You by the Scorps. Dead nuts in the middle between 2 notes when tuned to 440. Playing in either key sounds off to me...

But then again, I have peanut butter for ears, so there you go. :)

 
Most of the stuff I jam to, particularly on that guitar, is in standard. 
In that case, you might want to convert to mp3 the tracks you jam to and transpose them to the Cali's key... though re-learning them in (relative) drop-D can be more a PITA than fun. :(

Yes, you do need two! :)

 
Or they could tune their damned guitars in the Key of Our Lord instead of that heathen tongue in which they insist.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I suggest you need more guitars so you can have one Floyd in standard and one (or preferably more) in drop tunings.  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Or they could tune their damned guitars in the key of Our Lord instead of that heathen tongue in which they insist.
LMAO. As someone who regularly has to switch between gig axes tuned down half a step to D#  and my practice ax (the E standard tuned Diablo I keep in the office, near the Mac I use to learn tunes) I honestly have no difficulties going back and forth. I use Audacity to transpose any tune that's not already in E and I'm good to go.

ETA- the issues with hearing a song out of it's original, recorded key are lost on me as I'm more concerned with picking up the guitar parts. I have a specific play list on iTunes specifically for band tunes. Those are all in the key of E.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
LMAO. As someone who regularly has to switch between gig axes tuned down half a step to D#  and my practice ax (the E standard tuned Diablo I keep in the office, near the Mac I use to learn tunes) I honestly have no difficulties going back and forth. I use Audacity to transpose any tune that's not already in E and I'm good to go.

ETA- the issues with hearing a song out of it's original, recorded key are lost on me as I'm more concerned with picking up the guitar parts. I have a specific play list on iTunes specifically for band tunes. Those are all in the key of E.
I do something like that too, though I create my own mp3 playlists tuned down to the band's tuning --I use Audacity as well.

BTW, tuning one half step down tends to produce "rounder" tones. In addition, it might be friendlier to the vocalist. I also sing and if I can't handle a song on its original key, I transpose it to fit my range. All singers appreciate that. The problem is however that many rock songs have riffs that cannot be easily transposed, and that's when detuning becomes a necessity.

 
It's my metal side.  I read an interview once with Mikael Akerfeldt of Opeth where he mentioned that alternate tuning for ideas was one thing, but retuning for "heaviness" was cheating a bit as good songwriters can write a song plenty heavy in standard.  I kind of took that to heart, though I do use Drop D and Drop B here and there. 

I mean, is this not heavy enough?
 


However, Tony Iommi can do whatever he wants. 

 
I do something like that too, though I create my own mp3 playlists tuned down to the band's tuning --I use Audacity as well.

BTW, tuning one half step down tends to produce "rounder" tones. In addition, it might be friendlier to the vocalist. I also sing and if I can't handle a song on its original key, I transpose it to fit my range. All singers appreciate that. The problem is however that many rock songs have riffs that cannot be easily transposed, and that's when detuning becomes a necessity.
Oh, the  half step down tuning is totally for the benefit of the singer. Poor ol' boy can't hit a lot of those grabyerballs hair metal notes anymore. As it is, there's a tune we're working on that we might have to drop another half step for him to hit. It's all good. Other than a little slop to the strings, it makes little difference to me.

 
Oh, the  half step down tuning is totally for the benefit of the singer. Poor ol' boy can't hit a lot of those grabyerballs hair metal notes anymore. As it is, there's a tune we're working on that we might have to drop another half step for him to hit. It's all good. Other than a little slop to the strings, it makes little difference to me.
You're a good team player! :)  

 
Back
Top