NITRO CELLULOSE

Most finish guys are also players and share the opinion that any finish, if applied properly, has no more effect on tone than another.

The majority of players with little to no practical knowledge of finishes, and seem to feel the type of finish makes a very discernible difference.

I tend to side with the finish guys, but don't have a strong preference one way or the other in what I play.
Well...I am a finish guy AND a player. I have been playing for a long time..have played all over the country including Madison Square Garden and to my ears..which are very discerning...finish material has an effect on tone....of course up to a certain point. A guitar finshed in heavy polyester will not sound as good as one with no finish or a nitro finish. A guitar with a thin finish of other material will sound more similar.

 
Just cause I'm the curious type, how many single guitars have you personally finished in some sort of poly (not a factory paint job), then stripped and refinished in nitro to compare?

The only comparisons I've seen have been factory paint to after market paint. Who's to say if it's the skill with which the finish is applied or the material itself?

 
I have a 2005 Hamer catalog that claims each guitar has 14 thin coats of lacquer. So is false and or misleading? Hamer guitars are my #1!

 
I have a 2005 Hamer catalog that claims each guitar has 14 thin coats of lacquer. So is false and or misleading? Hamer guitars are my #1!
Many here have seen it being done - not exactly 14 every time , say +/- one or two. Guitars went round on a track to get repeated coats. And the post-91 finish, as stated above, is a catalysed lacquer. So no - it's not misleading at all.

 
Maybe not intentional but I think it's a little misleading. They list it as lacquer and I'll wager that a fair number of people automatically think "nitro." when they read the word lacquer. Granted most product sheets are written by sales and marketing folks who don't know/don't care so like I said probably not intentional.

 
Words is words.............

If you want to be pedantic the word lacquer is derived from the lac bug (not a beetle) of India, shellac being made from its secretions (ughhh!). True beetle lacquer is a pretty ancient material in the Orient.

Cellulose nitrate is therefore, strictly speaking, a 20th century synthetic coating; cellulose acetate/butyrate is so close chemically they could both be considered lacquer in guitar-speak, as distinguished from polyester. But none of them are really lacquer in the true sense.

Guitar catalogues are full of nonsense and hyperbole but on this occasion I have to defend Hamer: it isn't misleading.

As an aside the lac is a true bug (hemiptera), whereas some (you know who you are) call bloody everything with more than four legs a bug. Which only goes to show how easily words can become corrupted.

 
Ever sit at a bar that has a clear coat so thick, they lay change and photos on it, then pure what looks like 2 inches of clear over it?

Well,

That's my '73 Fender Precision.

And it actually sounds great.

Of course it's heavily modified, so....

My Standard Bass rings/resonates like it were a violin.

Chalk one up for a paper thin lacquer finish and 1 piece of old growth mahogany.

 
Back
Top