Scale length/tuning/string gauge?

                                                                                                                        These work  well for me.
jJk8Xjs.png


 
Many years ago I had a guitar teacher that pretty much called me a pussy for playing 9s so I switched to 10 - 46 on everything and never went back.  Back then I didn't know anything about scale length and how that affected things.  Lately I've been experimenting with 9 - 46 on the 25.5" guitars and I'm liking the new feel.

 
9s, though I do like the warmer tone of heavier strings. Everything is in standard tuning except the Cali which stays in Eb, because I'm a Van Halen fanboy.

 
I must be a real outlier.....I almost always used 10s on everything historically. But I find myself leaning more towards 11s. Notwithstanding that I bend notes all over the place, even double stops.

Esp on a couple semi-hollows (one 24.75, the other 25.5) they really came alive when I bumped up from 10s.

FWIW, if a guitar is "built right", moving up to 11s is not so much a challenge as often feared.

 
I use 10-46 D'Addario EXL 110's on all of my electrics no matter the scale length. Have for decades.

 
In the beginning, when dinosaurs roamed the Earth (the early 1970s), there was Black Diamond strings. Big, heavy, unforgiving Black Diamond strings on a budget-quality acoustic guitar.

Then my guitar-playing neighbor and I got electric guitars and discovered the joys of an .008 set. It was a beautiful thing. As my playing skills progressed (along with the frustration of constantly breaking the high E string) I moved to .009s, and stayed with .009s for a long time.

After I got to GIT and basically had a guitar in my hands the entire day, I decided to see what would happen if I moved to .010s. Hardly felt any difference. So I slapped a set of .011s on my '81 Special and didn't even feel it. That was in 1988, and even though I don't get to practice as much as I did back then, that's what I've used on that guitar ever since: GHS Boomers GBM, .011 - .050. 

These days, though, all other the electrics get .010s -- regardless of scale length or tuning: standard, open-G, open-A or open-D.

Well, except my Tele, which gets Fender 150M Original Pure Nickel .011 - .049. Maybe I'm just a glutton for punishment, I don't know.

The Strat gets Fender Super Bullets (.010 - .046).

I used GHS Boomers (GBL .010 - .046) on several guitars for a long time but I started having some weird buzzing problems with the .026 (4th) around the 5th fret. I could replace that one string with something else (say, Ernie Ball) and the buzzing went away.

Since then I've tried a lot of different string brands. Dunlop Rev. Willy's Mexican Lottery Brand seem to go well with P-90s (although in the very un-Gibbons-like gauges of .010 - .046). I recently got some Dunlop Nickel Plated Steel (Med, .010 - .046) and those seem to be working all right.

Ernie Ball Nickel Regular Slinky (.010 - .046) is always an old standby. My Shishkov came with D'Addario XLs (.010 - .046), and I've continued that tradition on that guitar. The electric 12-strings get D'Addario EXL150s.

The bottom line is, I really don't notice all that much difference - with two exceptions:

-- .011s on the Tele sound huge but make it a bit of a beast to play, so if I'm planning on doing any Albert King-style bending it's not the guitar I go for. But it's great for nasty, Hound Dog Taylor-style tones (or if I'm playing a Johnny Cash song). And I can beat it like it owes me money and it doesn't go out of tune.

-- If I'm playing slide on a 24.75" scale guitar with .010s I have to use a slightly lighter touch with the slide.

I have a friend who's an amazing guitarist, but his field of expertise is metal: 7-string Floyd-equipped guitars with at least 24 frets, lowered tunings and ultra light strings practically laying on the frets. The other day he picked up my Duo-Tone: "Man, I can't even play this thing! There's only six strings, they're too heavy, they're tuned too high, the action's too high and there's not enough frets!"

 
11-49 on all electrics, no matter the scale lengths, both in regular tuning and Eb.

12-54 on all acoustics. 

Too much hassle with different string gauges ;)

 
I don't know what I play. I send my teenage daughter into the music shop (its right by her school) and she says, "my dad want some guitar strings" the guy says "what type of guitar does your dad play" and she says "a loud one" he then decides for her, and she gives them to me. I better ring him and ask what I've been playing all these years.

 
24.75" fixed bridge guitars get NYXL  11 - 48

25.5 fixed or wiggly bridge guitars get NYXL 10 - 46 unless they're tuned Eb. That gets the 11 set.  

This works well for me even with open tunings.

 
10-46... I may drop to 9’s tho, the arthritis isn’t getting any better, and I don’t play as much anymore.

 
Back
Top