In the beginning, when dinosaurs roamed the Earth (the early 1970s), there was Black Diamond strings. Big, heavy, unforgiving Black Diamond strings on a budget-quality acoustic guitar.
Then my guitar-playing neighbor and I got electric guitars and discovered the joys of an .008 set. It was a beautiful thing. As my playing skills progressed (along with the frustration of constantly breaking the high E string) I moved to .009s, and stayed with .009s for a long time.
After I got to GIT and basically had a guitar in my hands the entire day, I decided to see what would happen if I moved to .010s. Hardly felt any difference. So I slapped a set of .011s on my '81 Special and didn't even feel it. That was in 1988, and even though I don't get to practice as much as I did back then, that's what I've used on that guitar ever since: GHS Boomers GBM, .011 - .050.
These days, though, all other the electrics get .010s -- regardless of scale length or tuning: standard, open-G, open-A or open-D.
Well, except my Tele, which gets Fender 150M Original Pure Nickel .011 - .049. Maybe I'm just a glutton for punishment, I don't know.
The Strat gets Fender Super Bullets (.010 - .046).
I used GHS Boomers (GBL .010 - .046) on several guitars for a long time but I started having some weird buzzing problems with the .026 (4th) around the 5th fret. I could replace that one string with something else (say, Ernie Ball) and the buzzing went away.
Since then I've tried a lot of different string brands. Dunlop Rev. Willy's Mexican Lottery Brand seem to go well with P-90s (although in the very un-Gibbons-like gauges of .010 - .046). I recently got some Dunlop Nickel Plated Steel (Med, .010 - .046) and those seem to be working all right.
Ernie Ball Nickel Regular Slinky (.010 - .046) is always an old standby. My Shishkov came with D'Addario XLs (.010 - .046), and I've continued that tradition on that guitar. The electric 12-strings get D'Addario EXL150s.
The bottom line is, I really don't notice all that much difference - with two exceptions:
-- .011s on the Tele sound huge but make it a bit of a beast to play, so if I'm planning on doing any Albert King-style bending it's not the guitar I go for. But it's great for nasty, Hound Dog Taylor-style tones (or if I'm playing a Johnny Cash song). And I can beat it like it owes me money and it doesn't go out of tune.
-- If I'm playing slide on a 24.75" scale guitar with .010s I have to use a slightly lighter touch with the slide.
I have a friend who's an amazing guitarist, but his field of expertise is metal: 7-string Floyd-equipped guitars with at least 24 frets, lowered tunings and ultra light strings practically laying on the frets. The other day he picked up my Duo-Tone: "Man, I can't even play this thing! There's only six strings, they're too heavy, they're tuned too high, the action's too high and there's not enough frets!"