sq
sq
I'll play: an amazing chain of HFC events have led me to this incredible guitar
5. Murkat provided an exceptional tone cap that eliminated the "bright" problem
believe me when I say the "anvil through a plate glass window" problem is absolutely solved. Perfect (for me).
Can you please tell us know what tone cap you got for the guitar? (value, type, brand?)
I guess is does not affect the tone when tone knob is on 10, right?
So I guess you roll it of some to get the sound you want?
Let us in on the secret /emoticons/default_smile.png
The guitar was built with the Hamer-spec 0.01 µF cap. I had paid a visit to Murkat Manor back in January to pick up my fantastically reconditioned acoustic guitar, and to pick up some parts Murkat had set aside for me for a Strat project. Among those parts was a 0.022 µF cap that Murkat will hopefully chime in and provide the brand.
When I received the Senior it had PRS McCarty pickups in it. They sounded fine, but the guitar was very bright.
I had a Rio Genuine Texas available (I favor lower powered humbuckers) and one Saturday afternoon curiosity got the better of me - I put the Rio in the bridge - the guitar was harmonically rich, but even brighter (way too bright). I desoldered and checked the potentiometer values and they were very much within spec. Being a simpleton, I made the following association: Guitar too bright → up the cap value. I reached into the parts drawer and found an Orange Drop 0.022 µF, an old-school "Tropical Fish" 0.022 µF and then the magical Murkat 0.022 µF cap. Again, curiosity got the better of me and I stuck the Murkat cap in there. Bliss! The tone control sounded great at all values. Would any of the 0.022 µF caps have done the same thing? Assuming they all test at the same capacitance, theory says yes. However, an entire market has developed around the sonic differences between caps and I won't be drawn into that argument. All I know is this cap sounds fantastic in there and I'm not messing with it!
I should address the "no effect on 10" comment, as this comes up often enough. Yes, tone controls do have an effect on 10, and here's why. The tone circuit could be considered as a filtered drain along the middle of the "pipe" of the guitar's circuit. The filter only allows certain frequencies (dependent upon the value of the capacitor - the "filter") to "drain" out of the circuit. With the tone control on "0" the pot value is 0 kΩ (or really close to it), allowing nearly all of the highs (frequencies dictated by the cap) to drain to ground. As the tone control is increased in number, the value of the potentiometer increases, progressively closing off the drain until you get to "10" on the tone control. At that point, the Pot value is 500k (at least in a Hamer guitar) - the drain is closed up very much, but there are still highs getting through to ground (just not a lot of them). If you were to change to a 1MΩ pot, fewer highs would drain; a 250kΩ pot would allow for more (actually, the same amount as a 500kΩ
linear taper pot on 5).
The no-load pots found in some guitars can remove the tone circuit from the equation. At the no load pot's detent, the pot is removed from the circuit (resistance is infinite) and that is the place where the tone control would have no effect.
Edited to add: I found an old
PSA thread Murkat posted where a guy was selling them on eBay. They are called
".022uF 200V SUPER PUP MPY2522 Poly-Film Cap Axial Leads" in the auction. Don't see any on eBay right now...